Best Toilet Repair Kits of 2020

Updated
Why change your toilet when you can repair it?

Typically, toilets last between 10 to 12 years. However, the internal mechanisms are a different story. They are often made of plastic and have many moving parts. This makes them prone to malfunctions.

Rather than replacing the entire toilet, we look at the best toilet repair kits to see which ones are a cut above the rest.


How Are Toilet Repair Kits Used?

Toilet repair kits are used to turn a malfunctioning toilet back into a functioning one. From time to time, toilets go wrong, and the culprit is often the internal workings. Flush mechanisms, flanges and valves all fail, but toilet repair kits are a cost-effective and simple way to sort the problem without calling in the professionals.

In general, toilet repair kits are easy to install and only take minutes before you have a functioning toilet again.

Are Toilet Repair Kits Universal?

Most are universal, like the NEXT BY DANCO or the Fluidmaster repair kits. However, specific toilet manufacturers make repair kits that fit their toilet brand. Kohler is one that springs to mind. When you are purchasing your replacement kit, if it says “Universal” on the box, there’s a strong chance that it will fit your toilet.

Types of Toilet Repair Kits

Some kits come with flappers, while others have replacement valves. Others specifically replace the flushing mechanism. There are different types of toilet repair kits to suit each specific problem.

Make sure the one you choose best covers the issues you have with your toilet. That’s why it’s worth doing your research first to discover what the actual problem is with your toilet before you splash out on a repair kit. If you are still unsure, get a complete toilet repair kit to cover all your bases.

How To Know What Toilet Kit You Need

So, you have an issue with your toilet, and now it’s time to determine where the problem lies. Determining where the fault lies is easier said than done. Invest in research to get to the root of the malfunction.

Check the Flapper

If the toilet continuously runs, this can be a significant issue, especially because it increases the quantity of water you use. Check the flapper to see if it is completely sealing the flush valve. If not, that could be the culprit and the reason why water runs constantly.

Replacing the flapper might solve the issue, but you may have to consider swapping the entire valve.

Check the Water Supply

Check that there are no water leaks. This is a costly problem both in the amount of water you use and the damage that water does to the toilet, the bathroom, and potentially the floor. Turn the nut about an eighth. Then check the supply line and make sure the connection is sound to the supply valve. You might want to consider replacing the valve if it’s over 5 years old.

Check the Fill Valve

If the toilet runs continuously, there might be problems with the fill valve. If you see debris on the valve or think it might be too old, replacing it would be a sensible move. Sometimes they can be cleaned, but in the main, if it looks like it needs a new one, it probably does.

Check the Bolts and Gasket

Sometimes bolts and gaskets fail as a result of age and wear and tear. If your gasket is the culprit, get a repair kit that includes replacements.

Pros and Cons of Toilet Repair Kits

As with everything, there is an upside and a downside. Here are the main pros and cons of toilet repair kits.

PROS:
  • Money-saving.
  • Easier to install than a new toilet.
  • No plumbing skills needed.
  • Tailored kits for specific problems.
  • Affordable.
CONS:
  • Requires basic knowledge of fault first.
  • Detailed research to get the right kit.
  • One size fits all.

Things To Consider When Buying Toilet Repair Kits

Keep in mind some of the basic elements to look for when buying a toilet repair kit.

Toilet Size

Most water intake inlets are an accepted industry standard of 2 inches wide. However, some may differ, so make sure you have double-checked the measurements before buying the repair kit. If the sizes aren’t 2-inches, you may need to consult with your specific toilet maker to get the necessary parts to perform the repair. This is undoubtedly going to be more expensive.

Flapper and Fill Valve

Some toilet repair sets are specifically made for flapper and fill valves. Choose the kit to cater to the problem you are experiencing. If your toilet runs continuously, consider a replacement valve.

If you experience ghostly flushes, it could be the flapper. If you are unsure, get a kit that has both to cover every possibility.

Flush Capacity

Older toilets flush 3.5 gallons of water per flush, but modern varieties use as little as 1.28 gallons per flush. Consider the capacity of your flush and get a toilet kit to match.

Budget

Luckily, toilet repair kits are relatively affordable compared to replacing the entire toilet. Depending on the brand, it will only cost you a few dollars. Specific makers, like Kohler, charge a premium for spare parts thanks to a captive audience.

Warranty

Most toilet repair kits come with a warranty. Some are generous, giving you 5 years, while others provide shorter warranties. The length of the warranty is the way to tell how confident the manufacturer is about their product.


The Best Toilet Repair Kits of 2020

Two large companies dominate the toilet repair kit market, so finding a diverse selection has been a challenge. We managed to boil down our selection to the 10 best toilet repair kits to make your search easier.

1. Kohler Silent Fill Valve Kit

Best Silent Fill Toilet Valve Kit

Kohler Genuine Part Gp1083167 Silent Fill Valve Kit For All Kohler Class Five Toilets,12.5' x 3.5' x 3'
Check Price

This is a genuine Kohler part, so you can buy it with the confidence that it should fit your existing class 5 Kohler toilet. This silent-fill valve fills your water tank quietly, so you can flush at night without the fear of waking the kids or elderly relatives.

It is an adjustable valve kit, so it is universal in the sense that it fits all class 5 Kohler toilets, and once installed, it improves the flush rate and saves you water thanks to the fill-rate inserts. The great news is that Kohler engineers designed this repair valve kit, so you can rest easy that they know a thing or two about toilets.

PROS:
  • Genuine Kohler part.
  • Kohler designed and engineered.
  • Adjustable.
  • Quiet-fill facility.
  • Improves water flow and flush.
CONS:
  • May not be suitable for all toilets.
  • Only suitable for Kohler class 5 toilets.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 8.8
Dimensions (inches) 17 x 5 x 3.5
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Single
Warranty 1-year
Quiet fill Yes
Price $$

2. Fluidmaster 400CRP14 Universal Repair Kit

Best Universal Toilet Repair Kit

Fluidmaster 400CR Universal Toilet Fill Flapper Repair Kit for 2-Inch Flush Valves, Easy Install, Multicolor
Check Price

This repair kit is suitable for modern toilets and even older 3.5-gallon flushing models. It’s the reason we choose this as the best universal repair kit. It is durable, which shows in the warranty. Fluidmaster is so confident about the quality of their product, they issue it with a 5-year warranty for peace of mind.

This repair kit comes with an anti-siphon valve and is easy to install. The manufacturer claims it can install in just 10 minutes. It also has a 501 flapper with a microban to prevent malfunction due to excessive bacteria growth.

PROS:
  • Microban prevents bacterial growth.
  • Comes with a 501 flapper.
  • Fits 3.5-gallon toilets.
  • Quiet tank fill.
  • Great value.
CONS:
  • Flapper has too much hinge friction.
  • Gets stuck in the open position.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 9.6
Dimensions (inches) 3.71 x 6 x 15.76
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Single
Warranty 5-year
Quiet fill Yes
Price $

3. NEXT BY DANCO Toilet Flange Repair Kit

Best Toilet Flange Repair Kit

NEXT BY DANCO (10672X) HydroSeat Durable Toilet Flange Repair, Blue and Black, 1-Pack
Check Price

Sometimes you only need to repair one element of your toilet’s internal mechanisms, and more often than not, the toilet flange is the culprit when your toilet runs continuously. This Hydro-seal flange repair kit by DANCO is a handy spare to have.

It has a self-centering gasket that grips the toilet’s horn for a complete seal, while the bolts ensure the flange stays in position. It is constructed from powder-coated steel and has a hard-wearing rubber funnel to provide that security of a tight seal.

It also prevents any sewer or toilet smells from backing up through the pipes. It fits most standard toilets, so you can rest assured that this is a universal repair kit.

PROS:
  • Universal.
  • Self-centering gasket.
  • Powder-coated steel.
  • Prevents toilet smells.
CONS:
  • Works best with a wax ring (not included).
  • Only the bolts are stainless steel.
  • Prone to rusting.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 1 pound
Dimensions (inches) 7 x 1 x 7
Adjustable No
Dual or single flush N/A
Warranty 5-year
Quiet fill N/A
Price $$$

4. Korky 100BP Ultra High Performance Flapper Repair Kit

Best Toilet Flapper Repair Kit

Korky 100BP Ultra High Performance Flapper Fits Most Toilets - Long Lasting Rubber - Easy to Install - Made in USA, Small, Red
Check Price

This flapper repair kit is 100 percent American made. It is constructed from Chlorazone red rubber to make it hard-wearing and resistant to chlorine, bacteria, fungus, city water treatments and hard water.

This flapper kit is universal, fitting most makes and models, provided you have researched the size options correctly. The adjustable chain is stainless steel, so it is corrosive resistant, and the heavy-duty rubber even fits older toilet models. So, if you have a toilet with a 3.5 or even 5-gallon flush, this toilet flapper can cope.

PROS:
  • Chlorazone rubber construction.
  • Stainless steel chain.
  • Adjustable.
  • Fits older toilet models.
  • Super-affordable.
  • 100 percent American.
CONS:
  • Weak attachment bracket.
  • Hard to adjust.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 1.6
Dimensions (inches) 4 x 7 x 2
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush N/A
Warranty 5-year
Quiet fill N/A
Price $

5. Fluidmaster 400AKR Toilet Tank Repair Kit

Best Toilet Tank Repair Kit

Fluidmaster 400AKRP10 Toilet Tank Repair Kit, 2 inches, Assorted Colors
Check Price

This is an all-in-one toilet repair kit. It comes with everything you need to make your toilet feel like new. And the best news is it is a universal kit, so whatever make or model toilet you have, this kit will probably fit.

It comes with the flush, the flange, the flapper, wax ring, and bolts, nuts and washers. You can replace every element of the toilet’s mechanics with this kit. And once you fit it, you will marvel at the water-saving qualities of the Performax flapper. The toilet fill valve adjusts from 9 inches to 14 inches, making it a true superstar no matter what size of toilet you own.

PROS:
  • Complete repair kit.
  • Universal.
  • Adjustable fill valve.
  • Water-saving Performax flapper.
  • 5-year warranty.
CONS:
  • The floater gets stuck.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 8
Dimensions (inches) 4.3 x 7.4 x 13.9
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Both
Warranty 5-year
Quiet fill Yes
Price $$

6. Universal Toilet Fill Repair Kit

Best Adjustable Toilet Tank Repair Kit

Universal Toilet Fill Valve Kit Easy and Rapid Adjustable Water Line - Toilet Tank Repair Kit for Most Toilets - High Performance Toilet Replacement Part
Check Price

This is the easiest toilet repair kit to adjust. Simply wind the plastic nut, and the valve extends or retracts. It is quiet, fast-filling and compact. It stops impurities from damaging the valve thanks to a water filter inside the unit.

It adjusts in height from 7.8 inches to 13 inches to cater to all sizes and shapes of toilet tanks. Above all, thanks to the adjustable stem, it is easy to install and saves you water, which saves you dollars. You can even adjust the water flow rate as well as the valve to prevent water wastage.

PROS:
  • Easy adjustment.
  • Saves water.
  • Fits most toilet tanks.
  • Water filter.
  • Adjustable water flow rate.
CONS:
  • Hard to follow instructions.
  • Not suitable for hard water.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 7.2
Dimensions (inches) 9.9 x 3.7 x 2.8
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Single
Warranty Not stated
Quiet fill Yes
Price $$$

7. Fluidmaster 400AH Performax

Best Toilet Repair Kit for Warranty

Fluidmaster 400ARHR 09042001931 Fit for HET 1.28 gal, 400AH PerforMAX Universal High Performance Toilet Fill Valve
Check Price

If you want peace of mind when buying your toilet repair kit, look no further than this Fluidmaster 400AH. It comes with a 7-year warranty. That is an industry-leading guarantee against defects with their product.

So, how good is it? First, it’s a universal kit, so it should fit in most toilets. Second, it height-adjusts from 10 inches to 15 inches, making it suitable for older toilet tanks where the capacity was 3.5 gallons or even 5 gallons. So, if you have a toilet that predates 1994, you are in luck.

Third, it reduces the noise your toilet makes as it fills the tank, thanks to a slow-filling and powerful valve. That said, it has twice the refill rate than standard refill valves.

PROS:
  • Universal fitting.
  • Fits pre-1994 toilets.
  • Works with dual flush systems.
  • Works with high-efficiency toilets.
  • Easy to install.
  • Easy to adjust.
CONS:
  • Not as quiet as the maker’s claim.
  • Takes forever to fill the tank.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 11.2
Dimensions (inches) 3.13 x 12.5 x 4.5
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Both
Warranty 7-year
Quiet flush Yes
Price $

8. DANCO Toilet Tank Repair Kit

Best Toilet Flush Repair Kit

DANCO Universal Toilet Tank Repair Kit, 1-Pack (80816)
Check Price

This universal kit differs from the rest because it comes supplied with a spring, a ballcock and a float with a rod. While it is universal, it replaces flappers that fit 2-inch toilet valves. It’s easy to install and constructed from durable plastic and rubber.

The fill-valve stands 8.5 inches tall, and the length of the brass rod is 7.75 inches. With the float on the end of the rod, the total measurement is 11.75 inches. What makes this kit unique is the ease of installation with the most basic of tools.

PROS:
  • Easy to install.
  • Ballcock design.
  • Universal.
  • Durable plastic and rubber.
CONS:
  • Not easy to adjust float level.
  • No instructions.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 8.8
Dimensions (inches) 4 x 7.4 x 13
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Single
Warranty 1-year
Quiet flush No
Price $$

9. NEXT BY DANCO Hydroright Water-Saving repair Kit

Best Water-Saving Toilet Repair Kit

Next by Danco HYR460 Lever Handle Replacement HyrdroRight Universal Water-Saving Toilet Repair Kit with Dual Flush Valve, Push Btton, White
Check Price

This DANCO Hydroright kit saves you up to 70 percent more water. That means you can convert your old high-capacity toilet tank into an eco-toilet by calibrating the exact amount of water needed for each flush. This kit covers all the bases; it has a dual-flush capability, and it even comes with a European-style push-button flush mechanism.

The best thing about this toilet kit is the smart tech that detects leaks and signals when the leak is found. It is chlorine and chemical-resistant and will not warp. It is adjustable in height and requires no tools to install it correctly.

PROS:
  • Push-button flush.
  • 70 percent water savings.
  • Chemical resistant.
  • No tools required.
  • Universal.
CONS:
  • Not suitable for Mansfield toilets.
  • Prone to leaking from rubber gasket.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 1.55 pounds
Dimensions (inches) 7.2 x 3.5 x 12.6
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Dual
Warranty 5-year
Quiet flush Yes
Price $$$

10. NEXT BY DANCO HYR270 Dual Flush Repair Kit

Best Dual Flush Repair Kit

Next by Danco HYR270 Hydroright Water-Saving Dual Flush Valve with Push-Button Handle
Check Price

A lot of newer model toilets have dual flush capabilities. If you care about the environment, invest in a dual flush toilet to cater to solids or liquids. So, this repair kit exclusively replaces your old dual flush mechanism when it malfunctions.

It fits standard 1.6-gallon tanks and 3.5-gallon older models, converting them into eco-friendly toilets in the process. Thanks to the design, it eliminates flappers, flapper chains, and toilet handles, simplifying them all into one unit. The flush comes courtesy of the push-button selector that sits on the top or side of the tank.

Like the other DANCO water-saving flush valve, this is chemical and chlorine resistant and it will not warp.

PROS:
  • Converts older toilets into high-efficiency units.
  • Universal.
  • Push-button selector.
  • No tools required.
  • Water-saving capabilities.
CONS:
  • Doesn’t fit Mansfield toilets.
  • Harder to install than claimed.
  • Costly if the complete unit fails.

Additional Specs

Weight (ounces) 14.4
Dimensions (inches) 4 x 3 x 10.5
Adjustable Yes
Dual or single flush Dual
Warranty 1-year
Quiet flush No
Price $$$

Toilet Repair Kit Comparison Chart

Product Best Weight Dimensions Adjustable Dual/Single flush Warranty Quiet fill
Kohler Silent Fill Valve Kit Toilet Valve 9 oz 17 x 5 x 3.5″ Yes Single 1-year Yes
Fluidmaster Universal Repair Kit Universal Kit 10 oz 3.71 x 6 x 15.76″ Yes Single 5-year Yes
NEXT BY DANCO Toilet Flange Kit Toilet Flange 1 lb 7 x 1 x 7″ No N/A 5-year N/A
Korky Ultra High Performance Toilet Flapper 1.6 oz 4 x 7 x 2″ Yes N/A 5-year N/A
Fluidmaster 400AKR Repair Kit Toilet Tank 8 oz 4.3 x 7.4 x 13.9″ Yes Both 5-year Yes
Universal Toilet Fill Repair Kit Adjustable Kit 7.2 oz 9.9 x 3.7 x 2.8″ Yes Single N/A Yes
Fluidmaster 400AH Performax Warranty 11 oz 3.13 x 12.5 x 4.5″ Yes Both 7-year Yes
DANCO Toilet Tank Repair Kit Toilet Flush 9 oz 4 x 7.4 x 13″ Yes Single 1-year No
NEXT BY DANCO Hydroright Kit Water-Saving 1.55 lbs 7.2 x 3.5 x 12.6″ Yes Dual 5-year Yes
NEXT BY DANCO HYR270 Repair Kit Dual Flush 14.4 oz 4 x 3 x 10.5″ Yes Dual 1-year No
Jump to the Full Toilet Repair Kit Reviews

Toilet Repair Kits FAQs

Can You Replace the Inside of a Toilet?

Yes, you can replace the inside of a toilet. A toilet consists of three elements, the ceramic bowl and tank, and the mechanical attachments. Because the bowl is so hard-wearing, most people experience little or no problems here. But the delicate inner workings of your toilet is a different story.

These parts wear out and malfunction a lot sooner than the ceramics.

When Should I Replace My Toilet Fill Valve?

Consider replacing your fill valve every 5 years. While it may still function correctly, like all plastic elements that are delicate and part of a mechanism. Replacement before they fail is prudent to avoid problems later down the line.

How Do I Make My Toilet Flush Stronger?

One simple way to increase the toilet flush power is to squirt a thick bleach into the toilet bowl, making sure the detergent coats the flush holes under the rim. Allow it to sit for 30 minutes before flushing it away. It will unclog any outlets that are restricting the flow of the water into the bowl.

You could also adjust the valve located at the base of your tank at the rear. It controls the flow of water into the toilet. Twist it one quarter turn to make sure it is fully open. This ensures the correct flow into the tank and, subsequently, the best pressure when you flush.


Flushed With Success

If you have an aging toilet, it might be an idea to upgrade the mechanisms rather than the toilet suite itself. It is cheaper and a better alternative if you want an instant result. Most toilet repair kits can be fitted in minutes, and many require no skills or tools.

So, if you have a continuously running toilet, or want to signal to the world your eco intentions, consider investing in a toilet repair kit. When the toilet breaks, you will be ready.

Headshot of mark

About the Author

Mark Weir

Mark spent 24 years working in real estate, so he knows his way around a home. He also worked with contractors and experts, advising them on issues of planning, investments, and renovations. Mark is no stranger to hands-on experience, having renovated his own home and many properties for resale. He likes nothing better than seeing a project through to completion.
3 Ways to Remove Hard Water Stains from a Toilet (Naturally!)How to Remove Hard Water Stains from a Toilet
Best Toilet Plungers of 20207 Best Toilet Plungers (2020 Reviews)
Best Toilet Cleaners for Septic Tanks of 20205 Best Toilet Cleaners for Septic Tanks (2020 Reviews)
Best Toilet Seats For Heavy People of 20206 Best Toilet Seats For Heavy People (2020 Reviews)
Best Wooden Toilet Seats of 20205 Best Wooden Toilet Seats (2020 Reviews)
9 Types of Toilet Flush Systems (Pros and Cons)Common Types of Toilet Flush Systems: Getting Rid of the Waste

Leave a Comment