Shower pans might not be the first thing you think of when buying a new shower enclosure, as they are less obvious than doors or walls. However, trays are important parts of any shower, collecting and draining water, as well as providing a safe surface for you to stand on.
There is a huge number of shower pans to choose from today, of various sizes and designed to be installed in different areas of your bathroom. With so many options, your biggest challenge will probably be deciding on a specific pan.
To help you find the right model for your bathroom, we have reviewed seven of the best shower pans available today. We chose these products based on their material, shape, depth, and durability.
- High-quality composite
- Six-inch threshold
- Slip-resistant texture
- Doesn't require tiles
- Includes drain & flashings
- Base for a walk-in shower
- Sturdy acrylic material
- cUPC-certified
- Anti-slip surface
- Lifetime limited warranty
- Available in three colors
- 2 ¾-inch threshold
- UPC & CSA-certified
- Ready to install
- High-quality drain plate
- Composite material
- Budget-friendly
- Slip-resistant
- Ultra-thick enamel
- 3 ¼-inch threshold
- 80% recycled material
Review Methodology: At Sensible Digs, we ensure all our reviews, including those on the best shower pans, are thoroughly researched and tested. Our professional team draws on years of hands-on experience and uses a rigorous evaluation process. Our analyses involve comparing products, tracking performance, and scoring based on key criteria like durability, design, and ease of installation. We delve into the specifics of each product, from unique design choices to the user experience they offer. Our aim is to provide you with the most comprehensive, fact-based assessment so you can make informed decisions on your shower pan purchase. We painstakingly measure each product’s performance and rank them accordingly, providing you with the evidence you need to trust our recommendations.
The Best Shower Pans of 2024
You will have seemingly endless options to choose from when selecting a shower tray, in various shapes, sizes, and finishes. To save you from a potentially very long search, we have reviewed seven of the best shower pans available today. We chose these products based on their materials, durability, and versatility.
Bestbath Shower Base with Center Drain
Deepest Shower Pan
This square Bestbath shower base is compact enough to fit most bathrooms, and will even be suitable for many small condos and recreational vehicles. The waste hole is in the center of the base, and a drain plate is included with your purchase.
At six inches, the threshold is higher than the average pan, preventing water from overflowing. There is also a slip-resistant layer that makes it safer to step in and out when the surface is wet.
This base is made of sturdy composite material and coated with a 5-layer fiberglass gel coat. In addition to its watertight seals, it is also scratch and stain-resistant, meaning this shower tray should stay pristine for many years.
As it is made using light materials, this base should be easy to transport to your bathroom. It also comes ready to install, so you should be able to install it relatively quickly.
Pros
- High-quality composite material
- Six-inch threshold
- Slip-resistant surface
- Ready to install
Cons
- The threshold could be too high for people with limited mobility
Product Specs
| Shape | Square |
| Size | 30 x 30 x 7 inches |
| Color(s) | White |
| Material(s) | Composite with fiberglass gel coat |
| Unique Feature(s) | High threshold |
Our Ratings
User Experience
Tile Redi USA Barrier-Free Shower Pan
Best Walk-In Shower Pan
If you want a shower pan without a front threshold, allowing a wheelchair to roll in, this high-quality Tile Redi USA base is a great option.
With a rectangular shape, there is no obstacle when entering it, making it ideal for walk-in showers. The base is also designed to be tiled, and epoxy is included for this purpose. The resulting base should be both visually impressive and watertight.
This pan includes a round stainless steel drain plate that is very durable. Metallic flashing bars are also included to improve how watertight your shower enclosure is. They are meant to be fitted along the edges, with the wall tiles placed over the flashing bar.
This product fulfills both UL and ANSI standards and is protected by a 3-year limited warranty (1). Multiple customer reviews praise how light the base is, and how quickly it can be installed.
Pros
- Easy installation
- Includes stainless steel drain plate and flashings
- No threshold, for a walk-in shower
- Can be installed without tiles
Cons
- With no threshold, powerful showers could overflow
Product Specs
| Shape | Rectangular |
| Size | 35 x 57 x 7 inches |
| Color(s) | Polished chrome |
| Material(s) | Polyurethane |
| Unique Feature(s) | Walk-in base |
Our Ratings
Personal Perspective
DreamLine Neo-Angle Shower Base
Best Shower Pan for Mid-Sized Bathrooms
This neo-angle DreamLine shower pan has been designed to fit into any 90-degree corner. While it is slightly smaller than a square base, the prism shape makes the most of its size.
Neo-angle bases are usually installed with glass shower doors. This DreamLine prism design allows for a door opening of 34 inches, which will be enough for most people to enter comfortably.
The base is made of sturdy acrylic material reinforced with fiberglass for extra durability. The anti-slip surface greatly reduces the chance of injuries when entering and exiting the shower.
DreamLine products are cUPC-certified. They have undergone extensive testing to maintain high-quality standards. The drain itself is not included with this model, but the hole will fit standard 2-inch wastes.
Pros
- Makes the most of its compact size
- Made of sturdy acrylic material
- cUPC-certified
- Anti-slip surface
Cons
- Doesn’t include a drain plate
Product Specs
| Shape | Neo-angle |
| Size | 36 x 36 x 2 ¾ inches |
| Color(s) | Biscuit, black and white. |
| Material(s) | Acrylic reinforced with fiberglass |
| Unique Feature(s) | Neo-angle shape |
Our Ratings
Community Feedback
DreamLine Single Threshold Shower Base
Most Popular Shower Pan
This DreamLine base has a single threshold at the front and is designed to fit a three-wall alcove shower. It features a right, left, or central opening to install a 2-inch drain.
To help you match this shower pan to the rest of your bathroom design, it is available in three colors: biscuit, black or white. The base is made with non-porous, high-gloss acrylic material for improved durability and easier maintenance. It is also reinforced with fiberglass and has a SlipGrip layer to prevent falls.
The low 2 ¾-inch threshold provides easy entry and exit for people with limited mobility and creates a discrete, stylish look. Some customer reviews mention being able to install it easily without professional help.
Take Note
Pros
- cUPC-certified
- Lifetime lifetime warranty
- Available in three colors
- Low threshold
Cons
- A mortar base is needed before installation
Product Specs
| Shape | Rectangular |
| Size | 36 x 60 x 2 ¾ inches |
| Color(s) | White, back or biscuit |
| Material(s) | Acrylic reinforced with fiberglass |
| Unique Feature(s) | Low threshold |
Our Ratings
First-Hand Impression
Woodbridge Tileable Shower Base
Most Luxurious Shower Base
This bold Woodbridge shower base comes as a single piece that is ready to install. It is designed to have tiles placed over the bottom of the pan to create your own luxurious style.
This kit contains everything necessary to install the tiles yourself. It includes three aluminum bars and 12 pounds of tile epoxy adhesive. This should be enough to tile the entire floor of the pan.
Although different sizes are available, the square drain is always at the center of the base. Your purchase includes a 2-inch PVC drain and a stainless steel drain plate with a nickel finish.
This shower pan is tough against impacts and is scratch-resistant. It is also UPC and CSA-certified as a mark of its high-quality standards.
Pros
- UPC and CSA-certified
- Ready to install
- High-quality drain plate
- 3-year limited warranty
Cons
- Base material not specified
Product Specs
| Shape | Rectangular |
| Size | 60 x 36 x 6 inches |
| Color(s) | Black |
| Material(s) | Not specified |
| Unique Feature(s) | Tileable base, ready-to-use kit |
Our Ratings
User Experience
Proflo Square Shower Pan with Strainer
Most Economical Shower Pan
If you want a simple and effective shower pan without breaking the bank, this budget-friendly square base from Proflo is a great option.
The pan is a single molded piece to ensure it is watertight and for easier installation. Most customers were able to install the base alone without the help of a professional.
Despite being an economical option, this base is made of high-quality composite material with additional reinforcement. Its non-porous surface is able to resist stains, shocks, and heat, all of which are very important as you shower.
It has a non-slip top layer to prevent falls when getting in and out of the shower. Many reviewers said this product exceeded their expectations. If any issues occur, the manufacturer covers this product with a 12-month limited warranty.
Pros
- Made of composite material
- Easy installation
- Budget-friendly
- Anti-slip surface
Cons
- Short warranty
- Only available in white
Product Specs
| Shape | Square |
| Size | 35.25 x 35.25 x 7.75 inches |
| Color(s) | White |
| Material(s) | Composite material |
| Unique Feature(s) | None |
Our Ratings
Personal Perspective
Kohler 9054-0 Salient Shower Receptor
Most Multi-Functional Shower Pan
If you want a versatile shower tray, the rectangular Kohler Salient base is an excellent option. Its shape provides plenty of space to maneuver under your shower.
Made of sturdy materials with an ultra-thick enamel coating, it can hold a lot of weight. Its low 3 ¼-inch threshold provides easier entry and exit.
This unique base is made of a durable enameled cast iron that contains 80% recycled materials. It is designed to be installed in an alcove surrounded by three walls. Kohler provides a lifetime limited warranty.
You can also install a shower bench seat if you are unable to stand while showering or simply want to relax.
Pros
- Safety features
- Ultra-thick enamel
- Low threshold
- Recycled material
Cons
- Very expensive
Product Specs
| Shape | Rectangular |
| Size | 60 x 30 x 3 ¼ inches |
| Color(s) | White |
| Material(s) | Cast Iron |
| Unique Feature(s) | Right drain |
Our Ratings
Community Feedback
| Product | Best | Shape | Size | Color(s) | Material(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bestbath Shower Base | Deepest Shower Pan | Square | 30 x 30 x 7″ | White | Composite and fiberglass gel coat |
| Tile Redi USA Shower Pan | Walk-In Shower | Rectangular | 35 x 57 x 7″ | Polished chrome | Polyurethane |
| DreamLine Neo-Angle Shower Pan | Mid-Sized Bathrooms | Neo-angle | 36 x 36 x 2 ¾” | Biscuit, black & white | Acrylic reinforced with fiberglass |
| DreamLine Shower Base | Popular Choice | Rectangular | 36 x 60 x 2 ¾” | White, back or biscuit | Acrylic reinforced with fiberglass |
| Woodbridge Tileable Shower Base | Luxurious Choice | Rectangular | 60 x 36 x 6″ | Black | Not specified |
| Proflo Shower Pan | Economical Pick | Square | 35.25 x 35.25 x 7.75″ | White | Composite material |
| Kohler Salient Shower Receptor | Multi-Functional | Rectangular | 60 x 30 x 3 ¼ “ | White | Cast iron |
Shower Pan or Tiles?
If your bathroom floor is already tiled, you might be tempted to simply add a drain and install the shower above the tiles. This might be cheaper in the short term but it isn’t the most durable option.
Tiles will age and crack over time, allowing water through and potentially creating mold and mildew. The surrounding grout can be a weakness. Even the best waterproof grouts will eventually wear off and fail. You will then need to fix or replace the grout, a process that can be both costly and time-consuming.
Adding a pan over your tiles will make your shower area far more durable. They are sturdier and can resist shock and varying degrees of heat. Maintenance is minimal, and installation and replacement are also much simpler than applying tiles.
Shapes of Shower Pans
Pans are available in various shapes to accommodate every type of shower and bathroom design, as well as every installation location in your bathroom.
Main Designs
There are five main base shapes, each designed to fulfill a specific purpose:
- Quadrant base: This V-shaped pan is tucked in a corner and features round, enclosed doors. They are a great option when space is limited.
- Neo-angle base: These pans have a prism shape. They are suitable for mid-sized bathrooms and are also installed in a corner. The unique footprint provides more space than quadrant trays.
- D-shaped base: If a corner shower isn’t an option but you still want a compact tray, these pans are an excellent alternative. They have a round enclosure and can be installed against any flat wall.
- Square base: One of the most common types, square pans are easy to install and are suitable for both corners and flat walls.
- Rectangular base: For large bathrooms, spacious rectangular pans provide far more room to move around in. Some can even be tiled over to achieve a more luxurious look.
Number of Thresholds
The threshold number of a base describes how many sides won’t be adjacent to a wall. For example, a single-threshold base will be installed in an alcove and surrounded by three walls. A three-threshold pan, in contrast, is designed to only have one side attached to a wall panel.
Threshold Heights
Bases have edges of various heights — also known as thresholds. Deep pans can contain more water and prevent overflowing. On the other hand, pans with a low front threshold allow easier access.
When shopping for a base, you will see the following threshold types:
- Beveled: Beveled shower pans have a slight slope to accommodate wheelchairs. These products are usually ADA-compliant (2).
- Barrier-free: These pans allow you to enter the shower without any risk of tripping over the edge, as you don’t need to step up.
- Curbed: The front edge of curbed pans usually measures between a ½-inch to 6 inches high.
- Temporary: This versatile threshold can be removed to accommodate all members of a household.
Shower Pan Materials
The material used to make a shower pan will have a significant impact on its quality, durability, and price.
Acrylic Bases
Much like bathtubs, acrylic is currently the most popular shower pan material. It is lightweight, making it easy to transport and install.
Acrylic pans are also very durable and often reinforced with other high-quality materials, such as fiberglass (3). They are also one of the most budget-friendly options, making them ideal if you don’t want to spend a large amount of money on your shower enclosure.
Fiberglass Bases
Fiberglass bases are usually cheaper than acrylic. They are made of a combination of polyester resin and woven glass fiber. Although they are even lighter than acrylic, they are also less durable; the topcoat can wear off over time, allowing water to seep into the tray itself.
Composite Bases
Composite pans are extremely durable, as well as among the lightest types. A high-quality composite base should comfortably last you more than a decade. However, they they are also among the most expensive pans, which might put them beyond your budget.
Porcelain Bases
Porcelain is another sturdy shower base material. It can comfortably hold heavy weights and will remain in pristine condition for many years with proper care.
The main drawbacks are that they are more expensive than other types and heavier, making them more difficult to install. This means they might not be the best option for an inexperienced DIYer.
Tiled Bases
These bases are designed to have tiles mounted in the pan. This creates a unique and luxurious look but they also have a few drawbacks.
Tiles are usually less durable than other materials. The grout holding them in place will need to be regularly cleaned and eventually replaced. Tiled bases also have additional labor costs and you will need to pay extra for the tiles.
Other Features to Look For
In addition to the shape, threshold, and material of a shower pan, you should also consider these points when shopping:
Stain resistance
Shower trays are frequently exposed to dirty and soapy water, which can soon leave them stained. It is important to choose a stain-resistant tray, particularly if it is lightly colored.
Scratch resistance
Shower pans need to be tough to prevent scratches. From dropping shampoo bottles to using abrasive cleaning tools, choosing a scratch-free material will ensure your pan stays pristine.
Cleaning agent
Some materials — such as acrylic — can be damaged by harsh chemical cleaners. Using natural solutions, such as white vinegar and water, will help protect your shower tray.
Drain location
Ensure that the hole at the bottom of the pan will fit above your drain pipe. Typically, drains are positioned at the center, rear corner, or sides of a base.
Colors
A matching base will complement the rest of your shower enclosure and bathroom. Shower pans are typically available in shades of black, white, gray, or beige.
Attached seat
Typically found on rectangular bases, a shower bench can be life-changing for people with limited mobility or anyone else who needs to sit down while showering.
Quality certifications
Choosing a product that is certified by a recognized organization means you can be confident in the quality of your shower pan — look for CSA, UPC, UL, or ANSI certifications.
FAQs
What Is the Life Expectancy of a Shower Pan?
A shower pan’s life expectancy varies between 10 and 45 years. Because it is often firmly fastened to the floor using bolts, sealant, and concrete, a shower pan should never experience any movement if the installation process is carried out appropriately.
But the passage of time can cause these tools to begin to deteriorate and result in movement. The materials used for securing anything can become dislodged if there are significant vibrations in the environment.
If you observe any strange slope in the shower pan, this could be a warning sign that the shower pan has deflected.
When deflection occurs, the floor beneath the pan might have water damage and is beginning to give out. Have this checked immediately, as it could pose an injury risk or could lead to structural house damage.
How Do You Clean a Shower Pan?
There are a few different ways to clean a shower pan, and the method you use will largely depend on the type of pan you have. If you have a metal shower pan, you want to use a mild soap and water solution to clean it.
You can also use vinegar and water solution to help remove any tough stains. If you have a plastic shower pan, then you can use a bleach and water solution to clean it. Just be sure to rinse the pan really good after cleaning it with bleach.
What Do You Put Under a Shower Pan?
Experts recommend using mortar under a shower pan. Even though a shower base is a rather straightforward component, it must be placed correctly for it to be of any use. A slope is already incorporated into the shower base because its primary purpose is to facilitate water drainage.
Which Is Better: Fiberglass or Acrylic Shower Pan?
A fiberglass shower pan is typically made of a plastic resin that gives it durability, strength, and resistance to chemicals. An acrylic pan is made of acrylic glass and resembles a fiberglass pan.
Each type has a few distinct advantages depending on the situation. Before deciding which is better for your renovation project, you need to consider whether the benefits outweigh the drawbacks.
Fiberglass shower pans are preferable when a high degree of moisture retention is called for. On the other hand, acrylic shower pans are ideal for those living in areas with high water pressure or looking for a material that requires little maintenance.
What Is the Difference Between a Shower Pan and a Shower Base?
A shower pan and a base provide the same function: direct water from the shower down the shower drain. Despite this, there are some subtle variances in the function that exist between the two.
A shower pan is a waterproof base upon which a shower curtain or enclosure will rest. The pan is just one of three components in a full bathroom remodel, including the walls, floor, and ceiling.
One of the main functions of a shower pan is to keep water from seeping through the subflooring into the home’s structure below.
A shower base provides additional functionality by providing the space in which plumbing pipes can be installed and providing stability for the feet of shower doors.
Which Type of Shower Pan Is the Best?
The DreamLine SlimLine DLT-1136600 is currently the best shower pan choice. This shower base features a center drain location and is designed for direct-to-studs installation. The SlimLine DLT-1136600 Shower Base is made of durable acrylic material.
It is available in multiple sizes to fit your needs. With its clean lines and low-profile design, the DreamLine SlimLine DLT-1136600 Shower Base will give your bathroom a chic, contemporary look.
